Artificial Intelligence in medical illustration: catastrophe or opportunity?

On January 31, 2025, BMC faculty members Shehryar Saharan and Nicholas Woolridge organized an AI information session for faculty and students. The session aimed to review the current state of AI, address ethical and practical concerns, and introduce helpful AI tools. The presentation, titled Artificial Intelligence in Scientific Visualization: A Catastropportunity, highlighted the dual potential of these technologies—catastrophic in some contexts and applications but also presenting opportunities. 

Contributors, including second year student Priya Modi, faculty Dave Mazierski and Derek Ng, and sessional lecturers Man-San Ma and Alexander Young, showed a variety their own experiments with and applications of generative AI in scientific visualization. 

AI tools and techniques have gained public attention in recent years with the release of chatbots like ChatGPT and Claude, and image generation tools like Dall-E and Stable Diffusion. These tools leverage advancements in AI techniques, such as neural networks, and the increasing power of specialized computer hardware. 

ChatGPT and Claude are large-language models (LLMs) trained on vast corpora of written information. Image generation models, trained on billions of images, often produce uncannily artistic-looking images. The availability of these technologies raises concerns about their impact on artists, writers, and other workers potentially displaced by their outputs. 

Medical illustrators are particularly concerned about whether these tools pose a threat to their profession. The workshop addressed some of these ethical concerns: 

  • Intellectual property: Many large datasets are sourced from human creators without consent or compensation. 

  • Privacy: Personal data can be inadvertently included in the training data due to the insatiable demand for data. 

  • Accountability: Most AI systems lack transparency about the source of their models or training data, making it challenging to assess ethics or assign responsibility for issues. 

  • Environmental impact: Training and running AI models are highly energy- and water-intensive

Human flourishing, equity, and human exploitation are all concerns that arise when considering the impact of AI on society. For instance, AI models can inadvertently reflect biases present in the culture from which they are developed, leading to potential discrimination and unfair treatment. Additionally, many individuals employed to review and validate AI outputs are often found in developing countries, where these positions may be characterized by low wages, unfair conditions, or exploitation. 

In the context of medical illustration, there are also practical concerns associated with the use of AI tools, particularly image generation. One significant challenge is the accuracy of AI systems. They can sometimes generate inaccurate or misleading images, which could potentially lead to errors or poor outcomes in medical applications. Another concern is the novelty of AI-generated content. While our field often involves depicting new biological phenomena, procedures, and devices, AI, which essentially remixes and regurgitates what it was trained on, is currently struggling to produce truly novel creations. 

Furthermore, organizations that rely on inaccurate AI-derived materials may face legal liability for errors or adverse consequences. Additionally, copyright issues arise with AI-generated images, as they are currently not protected by copyright law. This means that clients may have to consider the possibility that their AI-generated images could be reused or altered by others. 

There are tools available that by chance or design do not run into the ethical or practical concerns mentioned. These more ethical tools are typically trained on ethical datasets and have a more assistive rather than generative nature. For example, one recent tool from Adobe can separate glass reflections from objects behind the glass in photographs. Another tool integrated into the animation program Cascadeur can infer skeletal motion from video sources, which is particularly beneficial for 3D animation of human characters. Both of these tools were developed ethically and have the potential to accomplish tasks that were previously impossible or extremely challenging. 

Workshop co-organizers Saharan and Woolridge hope to offer another session in Summer 2025.

2025 Vesalius Trust Scholar–Molly Wells

Second year MScBMC student Molly Wells was named a 2025 Vesalius Trust Scholar for her master's research project Gully Deep Dive. Gully Deep Dive is an online interactive multi-media learning resource for high school students.

Congratulations Molly Wells on being named a 2025 Vesalius Trust Scholar.

Molly is a second-year graduate student in the Master of Science in Biomedical Communications at the University of Toronto. She received a Vesalius Trust scholarship for her master's research project Gully Deep Dive.

The Gully is a marine protected area 200 kilometres off the coast of Nova Scotia. Formed hundreds of thousands of years ago, the deep sea canyon's ecosystem is home to the endangered Northern bottlenose whale and a habitat for a wide variety of species.

Molly is developing an online interactive multi-media learning resource for the Gully. Designed for a high school audience, Gully Deep Dive will take students on a submarine simulation from the surface of the North Atlantic Ocean to the bottom of the deep submarine canyon–and out again.

The interactive learning resource will show students the marine life that calls the Gully home, what makes the deep-sea canyon so special, and how regulations protect the Gully while still allowing people to enjoy the ocean in a sustainable way.

The Vesalius Trust awards scholarships and research grants to students who have completed one year of curriculum in accredited medical illustration programs. These competitive awards are based on scholastic achievement and research project merit.

~

Vesalius Trust web site: https://vesaliustrust.org

Molly’s online presence:

Online Portfolio: https://www.mollywellsart.ca/science-visuals.html

LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/molly-wells-123064151/

Research Gate: https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Molly-Wells-4

Instagram: @mollywellsart

Vesalius Trust awards 2025 Research Grant to BMC grad student Bonnie Yuqing Wang

An image that includes the NerveUs logo, a short description of its purpose, and a mockup of the web site displayed on a laptop screen.  In the bottom right corner, there is a circular portrait of the project creator Bonnie Wang.

Bonnie Yuqing Wang, a second year MScBMC student, received a research grant from the Vesalius Trust to support her creation and development of an interactive educational tool for patients with peripheral nerve injury.

Congratulations Bonnie Yuqing Wang on being awarded a 2025 Vesalius Trust Research Grant.

A second-year student in the Master of Science in Biomedical Communications program at the University of Toronto, Bonnie received the grant for her master's research project NerveUs: developing an interactive educational tool for patients with peripheral nerve injury.

Peripheral nerve injury (PNI) occurs when nerves outside the central nervous system–for example, those in the arms and legs–are compressed or crushed. PNI can result in a loss of sensation or motor function.

Bonnie is developing an online interactive educational platform for patients with PNI. "Many patients have difficulty visualizing how nerves work, so they do not understand how PNI can impact their daily life until it happens to them," Bonnie says.

NerveUs will help patients understand the science behind PNI and various aspects of their treatment, such as the healthcare professionals they will see or the diagnostic tests they might undergo.

NerveUs will consist of a series of online modules that users can navigate sequentially or by going to a specific section, depending on their needs. Bonnie is designing and creating illustrations and animations, and writing text that is accessible to a general audience. Some modules will also feature interactive 3D models that patients will be able to explore from different perspectives.

Bonnie intends NerveUs to be a comprehensive resource that patients can revisit at different stages of their treatments for information and understanding.

The Vesalius Trust awards scholarships and research grants to students who have completed one year of curriculum in accredited medical illustration programs. These competitive awards are based on scholastic achievement and research project merit.

~

Vesalius Trust web site: https://vesaliustrust.org

Bonnie’s online presence:

Web site: https://www.bonniewang.ca

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/visualsbywang/

LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/bonnie-w-211566129/

BMC 80–Speaker Series 2025: Lisa Qiu, Art Director, Real Chemistry

Lisa Qiu, MScBMC ‘18 is an award-winning biomedical communicator with a passion for translating complex science, medicine and health into engaging visual solutions for diverse audiences.

from medical animation to art direction: navigating a career in biomedical communication

The BMC career journey is often unique, ever evolving and rarely predictable. In this talk, I’ll share my experience with production, art direction, and how it took me to the US and back. Learning the value of stepping outside restrictive professional silos, taking risks, exploring different roles and continuously expanding one’s toolkit can help navigate the ups and downs of a niche industry and, more importantly, find professional fulfillment. Join me as I share insights on adaptability, growth, and viewing our expertise as versatile assets across industries. My hope is to inspire others to explore, adapt, and redefine their paths in the ever-changing landscape of creative scientific communication.

Date: February 7, 2025
Time: 1 to 2 p.m.
Location: Online
Webinar Registration Link: https://utoronto.zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_ao_Pt8FNSv6qzoIBb4cm8g#/registration
2025 BMC speaker series full program: https://bmc.med.utoronto.ca/news-events/2025/01/29/bmc80-speaker-series-2025


LISA QIU, MScBMC ‘18. Lisa is currently an art director at Real Chemistry, a global health innovations company that provides marketing and tech-enabled services to healthcare companies. She specifically works under the medical communications division with the RadScience team, specializing in scientific visualization and storytelling through congress experiences. Lisa received her HBSc in pathobiology and MScBMC from the University of Toronto, and is a graduate of the Academy of Realist Art Toronto. Since completing the BMC program in 2018, Lisa has cultivated a range of production experience, having worked as a medical animator at Red Nucleus (formerly INVIVO Communications) in Toronto and a multimedia production artist at Real Chemistry in New Jersey/New York City. She is passionate about art and on her free time, Lisa enjoys making ceramics, baking fancy desserts, completing the New York Times crossword and sometimes running.

LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/lisa-qiu

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/lisauiq?igsh=bDh6cWN3dmRpbG5k

Real Chemistry Website: https://www.realchemistry.com/

BMC80–Speaker Series 2025

The BMC Speaker Series 2024 is pleased to welcome seasoned storytellers from diverse backgrounds including medical animation/illustration, surgical education, and beyond. These biomedical communication specialists will share their insights and techniques for transforming intricate subject matter into accessible visuals that captivate and enlighten audiences.

UNCON is back

Join the BMC Alumni Association (BMCAA) for a series of talks and workshops from BMC alumni and renowned professionals in the field. This year's speakers will cover everything from career talks to molecular landscapes to illustration principles. Dust off your drawing pencils! UNCON 2024 will take place both in-person and virtually, and all are welcome!

WHEN

Saturday, November 16, 2024, 11 a.m. to 7 p.m. ET
Doors open at 10:45 a.m. ET for in-person attendees.

WHERE

In-person: Room 1170, Bahen Centre for Information Technology, University of Toronto, 40 St George Street, Toronto, ON M5S 2E4

Virtual: via Zoom (A link will be sent to those who register for the virtual event.)

ADDITIONAL DETAILS

In-person

UNCON 2024 will be an amazing opportunity to connect with and learn from fellow alumni and industry experts in our field. The cost for in-person attendance is $10 and a light lunch/refreshments will be provided for registered attendees. All funds from UNCON will go directly to support future BMCAA events.

Virtual

For those unable to attend in-person, we will broadcast the event via Zoom. Online attendance is free and registered participants will be provided the Zoom link to attend. Satellite watch parties are highly encouraged! Gather with fellow alumni in your community and watch together.

REGISTRATION

Sign up to attend UNCON 2024 before November 14 to secure your spot!

https://www.eventbrite.ca/e/bmcaa-presents-uncon-2024-tickets-1063972453249

BMCAA Executive team
bmcaa.com
bmcaa@utoronto.ca

The BMCAA is generously sponsored by: BioRender, BioHues Digital and TVASurg.

~

Web links

BioHues Digital https://biohuesdigital.com

BioRender https://www.biorender.com

TVASurg https://pie.med.utoronto.ca/TVASurg/

UNCON Registration https://www.eventbrite.ca/e/bmcaa-presents-uncon-2024-tickets-1063972453249

MScBMC Open House 2024

Date & Location

Saturday, September 21, 2024 from 10 a.m. to 1 p.m. ET

  • 10 a.m. to 12 p.m. ET - pre-application reviews with BMC faculty

  • 12 to 12:30 p.m. ET - Director’s and student rep’s presentations, and Q&A

  • 12:30 to 1 p.m. ET - pre-application reviews with BMC faculty

University of Toronto Mississauga (Details to be provided when registrations are confirmed.)

For directions and campus maps, see https://bmc.med.utoronto.ca/visit-us.

About

The BMC Open House is an informal, casual opportunity for potential applicants to meet with students who are currently enrolled in the program, to tour BMC's facilities at UTM, and to meet with faculty. Potential applicants can request a pre-application review to help them assemble the strongest application possible when they do apply. This is not an interview. Attendance at the Open House is not a guarantee of admission.

Formal interviews for Fall 2025 admission will take place February 20, 2025 and are by invitation only. (See Important Dates.) Ideally, interviews will be in person. However, if interviews must take place on-line, the BMC Open House will have provided an opportunity for potential applicants to meet BMC faculty in person and to seek feedback on transcripts and art.

Pre-application review

For potential applicants who would like a pre-application review, there are available a limited number of 10-minute scheduled appointments with various faculty members.

Review the BMC faculty profiles and request an appointment with someone whose areas of specialization are of interest to you. https://bmc.med.utoronto.ca/faculty-staff

REGISTRATION Required FOR IN-PERSON ATTENDANCE

Attendees must register to attend, and must bring unofficial transcripts and art samples with them. Register here: https://forms.office.com/r/MH9B7S0Dt8.
Deadline to register: Thursday, September 12, 2024

ONLINE ATTENDANCE

Potential applicants who cannot attend in person but who wish to attend the director’s and student rep’s presentations, and the Q&A session, can register here: https://uoft.me/MScBMC-Open-House-Webinar-2024. Registrants will receive an email with the webinar link.

Biomedical Communications grad student illustrates cover of national dental publication

Jo Yeon Seul Choi, a second-year student in the Master of Science in Biomedical Communications program at the University of Toronto, created the cover illustration for the June 2024 issue of Oral Health magazine. Oral Health is a monthly clinical publication with a circulation of more than 22,000 dental professionals.

The Oral Health June editor Dr. Bruce Pynn, oral and maxillofacial surgeon and Chief of Dentistry at Thunder Bay Regional Hospital, contacted the Biomedical Communications (BMC) program with the opportunity.

A University of Toronto alum, Dr. Pynn says that he knew of the BMC program through collaborations in the 1990s with the Art as Applied to Medicine students. As a student, Dr. Pynn was the editor of the student dental journal. Art as Applied to Medicine was the undergraduate bachelor of science degree that preceded the graduate Master of Science in Biomedical Communications, which was established in 1994.

Choi’s illustration of a skull and brain depicts the rare but dire consequences of some dental infections where bacteria can travel to the brain.

Choi says that depicting the skull at a three-quarter view allowed her to show cavities in the molars. She overlaid the skull with a cross-section of the brain in situ, and referenced CT scans to accurately represent the size of an abscess. As there are many different bacteria that can cause infections, she illustrated representative shapes of cocci, rod-like, and spiral bacteria.

Choi says that she enjoyed the collaborative experience of working with Dr. Pynn, and their collaboration led to another cover illustration for Dental Update, a peer-reviewed clinical journal for general dental practitioners in the United Kingdom.

“They came out the same month on two different sides of the ocean. Quite a feat,” says Dr. Pynn.

~

Web sites referenced

Jo Choi’s online portfolio https://www.jochoi.ca/

Our History–From BSc to MSc https://bmc.med.utoronto.ca/projects

MScBMC student Juno Shemano awarded 2024 Vesalius Trust Research Grant

A second-year student in the Master of Science in Biomedical Communications program, Juno Shemano’s master’s research project was recognized with a 2024 Vesalius Trust Research Grant. Photo courtesy: J. Shemano

Juno Shemano, a second-year student in the Master of Science in Biomedical Communications program, was awarded a 2024 Vesalius Trust Research Grant for her master's research project Wound Watch: An interactive education platform on pressure injury prevention for unpaid caregivers.

Pressure injuries, also called bedsores, occur when blood flow to the skin and tissues is restricted through pressure; for example, from lying in bed or sitting in a wheelchair for prolonged periods of time.

Pressure injuries can become serious and result in the death of those tissues, bone infection, other complications arising from infections, and even death.

Unpaid caregivers, such as family, friends and neighbours, play an essential role in handling pressure injuries, but Juno’s literature search showed that existing educational resources are not created for these informal inexperienced caregivers.

Working with content advisor Sharon Gabison, researcher in rehabilitation science at the University Health Network, and BMC faculty advisor Michael Corrin, Juno is designing a public resource that will incorporate 3D interactive models, 2D visualizations, and animated illustrations. Each stage of pressure injuries will be depicted on the five most common risk areas of the human body.

Screen shot from the web site Wound Watch. Wound Watch is a publicly available educational resource created by Juno Shemano, MScBMC ‘24 specifically for unpaid caregivers. Image courtesy J. Shemano

Juno has designed Wound Watch to fill a gap in existing media by incorporating visual representations on darker skin. She is creating content that considers the right amount of visual complexity for the audience. And, she is striving to achieve the balance between providing distressing medical information in a sensitive manner, while still providing information vital to patient care.

The Wound Watch platform will be available in summer 2024.

MScBMC students who also received 2024 Vesalius Trust awards include:

Beatrice Nai-Jung Chen, MScBMC '24–Research Grant for her project A road map of health care transition to adult care for adolescents with paediatric heart disease

Jayne Leggatt, MScBMC '24–the Joyce McGill Scholarship for her project Sonoanatomy Atlas: An Interactive Educational Resource for Sonoanatomy and Ultrasound Protocol

Samantha Li, MScBMC '24–Research Grant for her project Storytelling with data: Teaching data-driven storytelling to undergraduate life science students

Natalie Lucas, MScBMC ‘24–Speaking from the heart: An audience-informed animation for navigating palliative care and advanced heart failure.

Vesalius Trust awards are made annually to recognize student research projects of merit.

~

Web sites referenced

Juno Shemano’s online portfolio https://www.junoshemano.com/

Beatrice Nai-Jung Chen’s Vesalius Trust Research Grant announcement https://uoft.me/vt2024-beatrice-chen

Jayne Leggatt’s Joyce McGill Scholarship announcement https://uoft.me/vt2024-jayne-leggatt

Samantha Li’s Vesalius Trust Research Grant announcement https://uoft.me/vt-2024-sam-li

Natalie Lucas’ Vesalius Trust Research Grant announcement https://uoft.me/vt-2024-natalie-lucas